The South Reports

Connect with us:


Hospitals in the ICU

Posted by
/ / 4 Comments
By Uma Sudhir
 

The police escort was in the line of a verbal firing. I was at Osmania General Hospital in Hyderabad, in the RMO’s room, where a convict brought in from Chanchalguda central prison for a medical check-up was bewildered, looking on in total confusion over what the fuss was all about.

Isko to ECG ke liye yahan bhijaye hai. Tum isko ultrasound ke liye kyon le gaye? (He has been sent here for an ECG, why did you take him for an ultrasound?)” asked the RMO, poring over the convict’s medical records, very angry.

Madam, ECG ka counter do ghante se band tha. Doosra room khula tha. Wahan paper dikhaye, tho woh test kiye aur report diye. Hamein kya maloom kya test karana, madam.” (ECG counter was closed for the last two hours. The other room was open. I showed the papers there and they did the test and gave the report. How do I know what test is to be done) was the escort constable’s reply. The RMO glared at him and if hitting a man in uniform was not an offence, she probably would have.

Kal court mein pesh karna hai, wahan heart attack aake mar gaya, tho court mein ultrasound ka report dikhaoge kya,” (Tomorrow he has to be produced in court. There if he dies of a heart attack, will you show his ultrasound report) the RMO was exasperated. The person incharge in the ultrasound section got a mouthful as well.

All that morning I had been trying track Rajitha, an eight-year-old orphan child, a victim of domestic abuse, who I had met the previous week at a government hospital in Mahbubnagar. I had learnt the child was brought to Shishu Vihar in Hyderabad. From there to Niloufer Superspeciality Hospital. I had to physically check the Children’s Ward there before finding out the child had been sent to Osmania Hosptial for an emergency orthopaedic surgery on her broken left arm that had since got infected.

I had rushed to Osmania so that I could see Rajitha before the child was wheeled in to the operation theatre. The surgery was to take place at 4 pm but even an hour later, no doctor or nurse was around to even find out when the surgery would take place. And the frail child was half unconscious, having eaten nothing since morning. That’s why I had gone in to see the RMO.

The RMO was responsive and immediately called the ward to check. “Rajitha was taken to the operation theatre about 15 minutes ago,” was the reply. “So if you wait for another 45 minutes, we would be able to tell you her condition post-surgery,” the RMO offered, pleased that not everything was wrong in her domain.

I thanked her and decided to go and wait outside the ortho ward where Rajitha had been admitted. Only to find Rajitha was still very much on her rexin bed, all shrivelled up. Whoever had answered the RMO’s phone had preferred to lie. Presuming that no one was going to come in and physically check in any case.

It took some more chasing before Rajitha was finally taken in for surgery. But not before a duty doctor came in and poked the back of her palm (for the drip) with a blunt, fat needle apparently meant for adults. The nurse pointed that out to him when Rajitha bled and screamed. After all she was already a very weak child, only bones, no flesh or muscle, weighing less than 12 kg even though she was 8 years old.

But then these are `minor’ errors for which no one asks any questions. There are a lot more grave things to worry about in hospitals like this one.

All around the ortho ward, in the corridors, everywhere, there were nightmarish scenes. People with broken bones, some in bandage, blood stains here and there, some waiting for attention, some screaming in pain, some too tired and defeated to even complain. All waiting in the hope that they would get the healing touch here and walk out healthy and well one day. After all, they have no other place to go. Government hospitals are the only place they can afford.

Overstretched, undermanned, often not run in either the most efficient or professional manner but that is what we have in the name of public hospitals all over the country. The sheer magnitude of the infrastructure is mind-boggling and yet it often seems a miracle that it provides healthcare to so many with the capacity to knock no other door.

I remembered what my colleague Sanjay Tiwari after a visit to Jagdalpur hospital in Chattisgarh in May 2010, where those injured in the Maoist attack on the civilian bus were admitted, requested the SP of Dantewada. That if the police could please try and get the blood-stained bedsheets changed. “It has been three days since they were admitted there, Sir and they have to sleep on those sheets, all blood-stained,” Sanjay explained.

“I will try,” promised the SP, pointing out how on the evening of the attack when the bodies were brought to the health centre at Sukma in Chhattisgarh, one of the first jobs he did was to sanction the purchase of bulbs to instal at the Centre. Shocking. Would the 40 W bulbs offer any light at the end of the hospital corridor, I had wondered.

I remember how a few years ago, a pregnant woman refused admission to a government hospital in Hyderabad, delivered her baby in the parking lot of the same hospital. The report provoked outrage. What did the government do? It banned the media from entering hospitals across Andhra Pradesh. The reality of the world inside hospitals need not be known to the world outside. Shoot the messenger. Problem solved.

When a jadoo ki jhappi cures the ailments of the public health service system in a hospital, the film is a superhit. Unfortunately in real life, the system needs much more than a jadoo ki jhappi.

 

(Uma Sudhir is Resident Editor, NDTV, based at Hyderabad and a documentary filmmaker)

 

  1. January 14, 2012

    Raamesh Gowri Raghavan

    Contrary to your experience, the example of my father and mother is quite different. My mother handled the domestic kingdom for a long time (30 married years), and has now decided to retire. She is now a globe-trotter, visiting family in far-off continents, taking pictures, etc. My father has now been given the task of staying at home and cooking, cleaning etc.

    The arrangement has worked out beautifully. Father was for all this time a kind of heir-designate, trained meticulously by mother to do all the work to my mother’s satisfaction. Now that he is the king of the household, he has managed quite well. In fact, I may even venture out to say that there are things he can cook where he has surpassed my mother.

  2. January 2, 2012

    Kinnera Murthy

    60% of the medical budget goes for Arogyasri and it certainly affects the rest of the medical system. If what you experienced in the main hospital of Hyderabad, can you imagine the plight of village PHCs? There were times when the staff in PHCs had to treat people with Paracetamol for everything. There are times when fresh MBBS doctors posted at PHCs have to undertake emergency deliveries with very little practical orientation in their curriculum and with just forceps (hopefully not rusted) as their main equipment. Many of the staff do even stay in the villages and often there is no medical help for the people. India’s best facilities are only for the urban rich and for medical tourism. I have learnt to respect the few people in the medical system, who, despite the killing constraints of the system, still try to do their best. They are the unsung heroes of an India that is not known.

  3. January 2, 2012

    Harika kiran Adiraju

    yes its true that the condition of govt hospitals is pathetic but is der any thing which can b changed??????

    yes der is!!!!!!!! I brooded over so many times to enter a new sysytem into Govt hospitals so that the infrastructure and the SOPs can be improvised…. but hw… der are many solutions but who r der to implement dem….

    Giv the young talent a chance to enter into the system and c a dramatic change….

    I wil wait fr dat time to come… but by den the disaster would hav already been done to a vast extent…

    so its upto the people sitting on those prestigious chairs who can help it out…

    its just the same slogan of India…JUST WAIT AND WATCH…

    Hw pathetic is our condition???????????

     hope I didnt hurt any1 by these words!!!!!!!!!!!

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.